Engine air filter OEM vs replacement

Placebo, it won't make any noticeable difference

 

K&n is crap, snake oil. Avoid them

 

There's no gain from them even in replacement cost. Even under dusty conditions, Toyota recommends a replacement at 36K miles or 3 years and simple inspections until then. A Wix replacement is $30 while a K&N is $65 so it will take you over 6 years or 72K miles to cover the cost of a K&N. Plus they are known to pass more dirt than paper.

 

Thanks for the feedback. Used it on my Tacoma with no issues. Will stick with OEM for now.

 

Plus reports of oil residue on in the intake and MAF sensor.

 

Placebo. If you want more fictional horsepower, rip out the carbon filter in the airbox lid when you aren't in California

BTW, Denso sells the primary air filter under P/N 143-3025, available from indie parts stores or online. Might save you some money avoiding Toyota and dealer markups.

 

I can honestly say that I didn't have issues running one on my Ranger but I just wouldn't now because there's no reason to.

 

Well, I went and got a Purolator One filter. Looks just like the thick OEM one with the pre-filter and truck is back to feeling normal again after running the thinner filter for a couple weeks.

 

I've had no issues what so ever. Been running them on every vehicle for engine and air cabin filter. Personally, I don't run them for any type of claimed gains, only the re usable factor. 2 cleanings and you've paid for it.

 

After another day running the Purolator One, the difference is night and day compared to the thin Toyota filter.

Now I’m wishing one of you would go get a Purolator to try in place of the thin filter so you can tell me this is all in my head. But seriously, the truck runs so much better. I’m amazed.

 

Interesting. I'll have to pick one up next time I change the filter, I've been buying the factory Toyota filters off Amazon, they've been coming in with the pre-filter.

 

Which Amazon seller are you using for the OEM?

FYI- I got the Purolator (A36122) at Autozone.

 

I don’t know enough about engines, filters, and air flow dynamics to speculate… but someone here pointed out the new thinner OEM filter has more pleats to compensate for the decrease in overall thickness from the original OEM filter.

I’ll point out this would also decrease the amount of “square inches” for air to pass through the filter’s surface plane.

If you increase the number of pleats to make the filter thinner but retain the same surface area of the filter medium, you’d also have to decrease the porosity of the filter to maintain the same amount of airflow.

 

You can remove the air filter and the truck will run the same.

 

What if you ran a very restrictive filter? What effect would that have?

 

A couple photos I grabbed off Amazon. New thin vs old thick OEM filters. And the Purolator, which has a metal screen over the top for reasons unknown.

 

I really liked the thick filter mine came with from the factory, but not because I could tell a difference. I’ve run the purolator one, the toyota OE thin replacement, and NAPA/Wix thick filter with prefilter. Couldn’t tell a lick of difference.

 

There is absolutely no measurable difference between all three. It's all placebo.
I had the thicker one last year, changed it to what the dealer had, which was the thinner one this year and will now get the Purolator.

 

Genuine Toyota - FJ CRUISER AIR FILTER NEW - 17801-38051

$29 Genuine Toyota - FJ CRUISER AIR FILTER NEW - 17801-38051

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B007OW62J0

 

Me too. Wholesale Toyota parts online. I have gotten several counterfeit parts from Amazon. I buy Toyota Wholesale online now. Prices are not that bad for real quality.

 

Well I just got the news. Mine are the same part number thin one bought from dealer this past Friday. Same part number as always. Nothin different but the thickness.

 

Ordered

$29 17801-38051 Genuine Toyota - FJ CRUISER AIR FILTER NEW - 17801-38051

17801-38051 from a dealership in Miami and received 17801-Y2213. Drove to my local dealer and got the 38051 for a few bucks more.

Pics of the two filters, both brand new: